How To Choose The Best Fishing Gear For Lake Erie
You’ve run tournaments and charters from the shallow Western mudlines to the wreck-strewn Central Basin — you know gear choice decides days. I’ve sorted thousands of lures and packs on Erie water; this roundup tells you what holds up in cold water, what actually draws walleye and perch, and what to grab for trolling, vertical jigging, shore work, or ice. Read this, outfit your boat or pack, and get on the fish when fall pushes them tight to structure.
⚡ Quick Answer: Best Lake Erie Fishing
Best Complete Starter Kit: PLUSINNO Fishing Lures, 137Pcs Tackle Box with Tackle Included, Crankbaits, Spoon, Hooks, Weights & Other Accessories, Fishing Bait Lure Gear Kit Gift for Men Bass Freshwater
$15.26 — Check price on Amazon →
Table of Contents
- Main Points
- Our Top Picks
- PLUSINNO Fishing Lures, 137Pcs Tackle Box with Tackle Included, Crankbaits, Spoon, Hooks, Weights & Other Accessories, Fishing Bait Lure Gear Kit Gift for Men Bass Freshwater
- Surf & Pier Fishing: The Gear, Tips, and Techniques to Get Started (Adventure Skills Guides)
- Piscifun Fishing Backpack with Rod Holder, Lightweight Sling Bag Storge Gear and Equipment
- Bass Fishing Lure, Fishing Spoons, Topwater Fishing Lures with Trebles Hooks, Trout Fishing Lures, Fishing Tackle for Freshwater and Saltwater, Fishing Gifts for Men
- 400+ Thrilling & Unbelievable Fishing Facts for Enthusiasts: Explore Legendary Anglers, Record-Breaking Catches, Cutting-Edge Techniques & Much More! ... Gift for Fishing Fans & Nature Lovers)
- Buying Guide
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
Main Points
- Treat value kits like the PLUSINNO 137‑pc as a parts box and backup — useful for spare spoons, split rings, and plastics, but for tournament runs swap the factory trebles and weak split rings before you fish deep Central Basin structure.
- Match lure to season and presentation: run topwater and small prop baits early summer on 6–12 ft flats, diving crankbaits that reach 8–25 ft for Western Basin spawn and spring patterns, and heavier spoons/vertical jigs in 20–50 ft during fall and ice when fish key on wrecks and edges.
- You need a carry system that moves with you — the Piscifun sling with rod holder is perfect for hopping piers, ramps, and quick practice rotations; make sure the bag sheds slush, keeps terminal tackle organized, and lets you rig a rod without unpacking everything.
- Size, finish, and hooks beat quantity: use 1/8–1/2 oz spoons for perch and shallow walleye work, 1/2–1+ oz for deeper jigging; favor chrome, gold, glow, or natural sardine finishes by water clarity, and upgrade factory hooks to VMC or Gamakatsu for cold‑water strength.
- Use targeted reading to sharpen your shore and seasonal game — the Surf & Pier guide tightens your shore rigs and casting angles on Erie piers, while a facts/reference book keeps past patterns and tournament lines in your head; then validate every adjustment on the water in both Western and Central Basin conditions.
Our Top Picks
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
PLUSINNO Fishing Lures, 137Pcs Tackle Box with Tackle Included, Crankbaits, Spoon, Hooks, Weights & Other Accessories, Fishing Bait Lure Gear Kit Gift for Men Bass Freshwater
🏆 Best For: Best Complete Starter Kit
This PLUSINNO 137-piece kit earns the "Best Complete Starter Kit" slot because it gives you immediate, lake-ready options for the varied conditions you face on Lake Erie. For $15.26 you get crankbaits, spoons, assorted hooks, split rings, weights and a compartmented box — enough to outfit a boat for a charter or a weekend of scouting. The volume and range are exactly what you want when you need to swap lures fast between Western Basin rock piles and the never-same Central Basin flats.
What matters out here is versatility. The metal spoons in the kit work for vertical perch and early-ice jigging; the smaller crankbaits and minnows cover shallow trolling and casting in the Western Basin around reefs and breaklines; assorted weights and hooks let you rig quick bottom bouncer rigs for walleye. Real-world benefit: you can build a basic 1/8–1/2 oz spoon setup for 10–20 foot jigging and shallow crank profiles for 6–12 foot runs without hunting for parts. Note the low price — expect entry-level materials, so plan to upgrade hooks and split rings if you’re targeting big Erie walleye during fall transition or running tournament-style presentations.
If you run charters, bring one of these as a guest box. If you’re new to Erie or prepping a shore-to-boat switch, this kit saves time and money. Use it spring through early fall for perch, smallmouth, and learning walleye patterns; spoons here are handy through ice season for panfish and quick jigging. For tournament anglers or deep-Central Basin fall walleye runs below the thermocline, consider this a stopgap — combine it with heavier spoons, quality trebles, and a downrigger or lead-core line for consistent 18–30 foot presentations.
Honest caveats: hooks and split rings are thin and corrode faster than premium gear, so upgrade before you push for big fish or long seasons. Soft plastics will stiffen in prolonged cold, reducing action on ice — metal pieces hold up better. Finally, you won't get deepwater-specific tools (heavy trolling spoons, downrigger clips) in this box; it's breadth over pro-level depth.
✅ Pros
- Huge assortment of lures and hardware
- Very low price for 137 pieces
- Useful spoons for jigging and ice
❌ Cons
- Hooks need upgrading for bigger fish
- Plastics stiffen in cold water
- Key Ingredient: breadth of lures for varied Lake Erie structure
- Scent Profile: none — visual and vibration focused
- Best For: Best Complete Starter Kit
- Size / Volume: 137 pieces with compartmented tackle box
- Seasonal Use: spring, summer, early fall, usable for ice panfish
- Technique Notes: good for trolling, casting, jigging; upgrade for deep trolling
-
Surf & Pier Fishing: The Gear, Tips, and Techniques to Get Started (Adventure Skills Guides)
🏆 Best For: Best for Coastal Beginners
What earns Surf & Pier Fishing the "Best for Coastal Beginners" slot is its straight-shooting, shore-focused curriculum that gets you fishing from Lake Erie piers and beaches fast. For eight bucks you get clear rig diagrams, step-by-step knot and cast instruction, and a compact gear checklist that prevents the common rookie mistake of showing up with the wrong sinker or terminal tackle. If you're new to Erie shoreline work—especially the crowded piers in the Central Basin—this book removes the guesswork so you can put bait in the water and start catching fish.
Key features are practical and immediately usable: illustrated rigs for slip-sinker and float setups, basic species-specific bait notes, safety reminders for pier and surf conditions, and short technique sections on casting, bait presentation, and reading shoreline structure. In the real world on Lake Erie that translates to fewer wasted trips—you're set up to target perch from summer drop-offs, to fish jigs for walleye near riprap in spring and fall, and to adjust quickly when the wind-driven Western Basin pushes bait schools tight to shore.
Buy this if you fish from shore or pier and need a compact primer you can reference between trips. It's ideal for anglers who already know how to cast but need shore-specific setups: light spinning rods in the 6'6"–7' range, 1/8–3/8 oz jigs for perch, and slip-sinker rigs for walleye in 6–20 feet of water off a pier. Use it for summer evening perch sessions in the Central Basin and for spring/fall walleye windows along the Western Basin shorelines when schools hug the breaklines.
Honest caveats: the book is introductory and lacks in-depth Lake Erie-specific tactics, advanced jigging methods, and boat- or ice-fishing coverage. At a 3.6 rating you'll find some generalities and a few regional nuances missing—don't expect tournament-level tactics or brand-specific tackle comparisons. Consider this a solid shore primer, not your complete Lake Erie playbook.
✅ Pros
- Clear shore rig diagrams
- Compact, easy-to-carry format
- Practical pier and surf safety notes
❌ Cons
- Lacks detailed Lake Erie specifics
- Minimal advanced jigging techniques
- Key Ingredient: shore- and pier-focused rig setups
- Best For: new coastal anglers on Lake Erie piers
- Techniques Covered: casting, slip-sinker, float rigs, basic jigs
- Seasonality: spring and fall walleye; summer perch
- Recommended Tackle: 6'6"–7' spinning rods, light reels
- Special Feature: illustrated knots and gear checklist
-
Piscifun Fishing Backpack with Rod Holder, Lightweight Sling Bag Storge Gear and Equipment
🏆 Best For: Best Hands-Free Rod Carrier
What earns the Piscifun Fishing Backpack the "Best Hands-Free Rod Carrier" title is straightforward: it frees your hands without sacrificing rod security during hectic lake work. You'll clip a rigged walleye or perch rod into the external holder, sling the pack across your shoulder, and move from trolling motor to gunnel without fumbling. In tournament runs or fast drift days on the Western Basin, that speed and accessibility matters more than another pocket or two.
Built from lightweight, water-resistant nylon with a padded sling and external quick-clip sleeve, this bag keeps rods upright and guides protected while you net fish or bait hooks. Small zip compartments hold line clippers, a couple of spoons, and split-shot so you can switch from jigging to casting in seconds. It performs well moving between boat and jetty, and it won't soak through on a rainy launch.
You should buy this if you need mobility: kayak anglers, shoreline casters, and charter crew moving rods quickly during short-period drifts. It's ideal when you're targeting perch with 5–7' rods, or when you carry 6'6"–7'6" jigging rods for walleye in 20–40' Western Basin breaks. For Central Basin humps where you carry heavier 7'6"–8'6" trolling setups, it still works for a spare rod and quick swaps during tournaments.
Honest caveats: storage volume is compact — not a replacement for a full tackle pack or insulated electronics bag. Also expect plastic buckles to stiffen near freezing; it's useful for short ice access, but not ideal for prolonged sub-freezing exposure or lugging heavy conventional reels for long stretches.
✅ Pros
- True hands-free rod carrying
- Quick-access external rod clip
- Lightweight, water-resistant construction
❌ Cons
- Limited internal storage space
- Buckles stiffen near freezing temperatures
- Key Ingredient: Lightweight water-resistant nylon
- Carry Style: Single-strap sling with external rod sleeve
- Best For: Walleye jigging, perch shore trips, kayak use
- Size / Volume: Compact — holds 1–2 rods plus small tackle
- Rod Compatibility: Accepts rods up to ~8' with guides
- Cold Performance: Functional in cold; buckles may stiffen
-
Bass Fishing Lure, Fishing Spoons, Topwater Fishing Lures with Trebles Hooks, Trout Fishing Lures, Fishing Tackle for Freshwater and Saltwater, Fishing Gifts for Men
🏆 Best For: Best for Topwater Bass
What earns this inexpensive kit the "Best for Topwater Bass" slot is simple: it gives you flash, wake, and trebles ready to finish fish when bass are feeding confidently on the surface. In Lake Erie you don't always get long, clean topwater windows — but when you do, these spoons drive explosive surface strikes on shad-fed bass along the Western Basin weed edges and over Central Basin humps. At $13.99 and with a 4.7-star crowd rating, it’s the kind of backup that wins you a few extra bites during short-lived topwater periods in tournament mornings.
The kit's real strengths are straightforward. The assorted spoon profiles throw a heavy flash and a wake that triggers reaction hits; they cast surprisingly far for their size and ride high when you twitch or burn them. Each comes with treble hooks so you’ll get a higher hookup chance on quick surface blows. In practice you’ll find them deadly on smallmouth blitzes in spring and effective on aggressive largemouth near weedlines in late summer. They stand up to repeated slaps on the water, though you’ll want to inspect hooks after long days.
If you run tournaments or guides, buy a few packs and keep them on the dash. These are your go-to for dawn and dusk topwater sessions, calm mid-morning shad pushes in the Western Basin, and the short, furious fall topwater windows when bass chase bait near shore. Fish them on a fast-action medium rod, 10–15 lb braid with a 10–12 lb fluorocarbon leader, and use quick twitches interspersed with short burns. They live in the top 0–3 feet — perfect for surface-only situations where a popper or wakebait isn't required.
Honest caveats: the plated finishes will chip if you slam them into rock repeatedly, and the included trebles will dull faster than premium hooks — plan to replace or sharpen hooks if you're counting on them for a tournament. Also, while marketed for saltwater use, rinse them after any salt exposure to avoid corrosion; they’re optimized for fresh Lake Erie conditions.
✅ Pros
- Explosive surface flash and wake
- Great value per lure
- Ready-to-fish with included trebles
❌ Cons
- Plated finish chips on rock strikes
- Trebles dull and may need replacing
- Key Ingredient: high-flash metal profile
- Scent Profile: unscented, reaction-only trigger
- Best For: Best for Topwater Bass
- Size / Volume: assorted small-to-medium spoons
- Line / Rod Setup: 10–15 lb braid, 10–12 lb fluoro leader
- Special Feature: fitted treble hooks for quick hookups
-
400+ Thrilling & Unbelievable Fishing Facts for Enthusiasts: Explore Legendary Anglers, Record-Breaking Catches, Cutting-Edge Techniques & Much More! ... Gift for Fishing Fans & Nature Lovers)
🏆 Best For: Best Gift for Anglers
Ranked #5 and crowned the "Best Gift for Anglers" for good reason: at $10.99 and a 5.0-star rating, 400+ Thrilling & Unbelievable Fishing Facts is the compact, high-return stocking stuffer you hand someone before a Lake Erie trip. It tucks into a glovebox or life vest pocket and delivers bite-sized intel that sparks better decisions on the water — quick reminders about species behavior, famous local catches, and seasonal patterns that actually matter when you're chasing limits in the Western or Central Basin.
The book's strength is practicality. You get concise facts on walleye, perch, and bass behavior, plus historical records and technique notes you can apply immediately: ideal trolling speeds for Erie walleye (1.5–2.5 mph with shallow-diving crankbaits), typical jig weights for vertical work in 20–40 feet, and how fall breakline movement differs between the shallow Western Basin reefs and the deeper Central Basin mud. On a long transit or inside the ice house, those quick references settle crew arguments, sharpen strategy before a tournament, and remind you which seasons call for slow-rolled crankbaits versus tight-line jigging.
This is for anglers who already know their way around a rod and want an edge in conversation and planning — tournament anglers, guides, charter crews, and seasoned weekenders. Give it in late summer or early fall when crew discussions turn to migration patterns and fall staging; hand it out before ice season to get younger anglers excited about perch jigging and lake lore. It’s an ideal grab-and-go gift for mates who appreciate exact facts more than flashy gear.
Two honest caveats: it isn’t a technical rigging manual, so you won't find step-by-step knot-tying or detailed sonar charts. And because it’s a compendium, some entries are brief and uneven in depth — perfect for quick reference, less so if you want exhaustive, basin-specific depth tables.
✅ Pros
- Compact, glovebox-ready reference
- Wide species and technique coverage
- Inexpensive and highly giftable
❌ Cons
- Not a detailed rigging guide
- Fact depth varies by entry
- Key Feature: 400+ concise fishing facts
- Species Focus: walleye, perch, bass, general lake lore
- Best For: Best Gift for Anglers
- Size / Volume: pocketable paperback, quick-read format
- Seasonal Use: fall migration, summer trolling, ice perch tips
- Basin Relevance: Western Basin reefs and Central Basin deep-lines
Factors to Consider
Frequently Asked Questions
What rod and reel are best for Lake Erie walleye trolling?
Use a 7'–7'6" medium action rod paired with a sealed baitcast or spinning reel that holds 200–300 yards of 10–20 lb braid. For downrigger or leadcore trolling you want a reel with a smooth drag and corrosion-resistant internals; gear ratios around 6.3:1 give good line pickup without fighting lure action.
How deep should I troll for walleye in the fall on Erie?
In the Western Basin expect to start 15–40 ft and move deeper onto humps or edges as the fall progresses; in the Central Basin and over main-lake structure you’ll commonly be fishing 40–80+ ft. Use your electronics to find thermoclines and bait schools, then get baits into that specific band with downriggers or leadcore.
Which line is best for perch and ice fishing on Lake Erie?
For perch through the ice run 4–6 lb fluorocarbon or mono on short ice rods so you feel every tap and get quick hooksets. Use tungsten jigs in the 1/64–1/16 oz range and keep a light fluorocarbon leader to minimize visibility in clear winter water.
Do I need side-scan or forward-looking sonar for Erie fishing?
Yes — side-scan helps you pick out humps, ledges, and bait concentrations across wide flats in the Western Basin, while forward-looking sonar is invaluable for locating suspended walleyes and vertical jigging targets in the Central Basin. If you run tournaments, dual-frequency CHIRP with structure scan is practically mandatory for repeatable marks.
What safety gear is essential for late-season Lake Erie trips?
Wear a comfortable, movement-friendly PFD and carry a throwable, VHF radio, GPS, and an automatic bilge pump or high-capacity manual pump. Add a cold-water suit for late fall trips and a clear float plan; conditions can change rapidly between Western and Central fishing grounds.
How should I protect reels and electronics from Erie’s corrosive conditions?
Rinse equipment with fresh water after every use and apply a light, corrosion-inhibiting lubricant to reel internals during winter storage. Use sealed bearings and reels labeled for saltwater or salt-resistant use, and keep spare parts like drag washers and bearings on board during tournament weeks.
What lures and presentations work best for Erie walleye tournaments?
Slow-trolled crawler harnesses, deep-diving crankbaits, and jigging spoons are the consistent producers; present them where thermocline and current intersect along humps. In fall, slow your presentation, run larger profile baits at targeted depths, and be ready to switch to tight-lipped spoons or vertical jigs when fish move tight to structure.
Conclusion
Equip yourself with matched rods and reels, corrosion-resistant electronics, and a sensible safety setup tuned to Western or Central Basin conditions. Prioritize depth control and durable line choices — and bring the ice gear when fall turns to winter; those who prepare for depth and cold consistently put more fish in the box.
