Best Tackle Boxes For Lake Erie Fishing
You fish Lake Erie long enough to know your box has to be as tough as the weather and as fast to grab. Western Basin mornings demand rugged, versatile storage for cranks, spoons, and jigs, while Central Basin days want quick access as you switch between trolling passes and jig runs. This roundup cuts through the hype to show which boxes survive cold water, keep lures ready for walleye and perch, and fit real boat work—from trolling boards to ice shacks. From fall patterns to tournament context, these five systems cover the depths and techniques you actually use on Erie.
⚡ Quick Answer: Best Lake Erie Fishing
Best for Large Tackle Kits: Plano Angled Tackle System with Three 3560 Stowaway Boxes, Fishing Tackle Storage, Premium Tackle Storage
$31.99 — Check price on Amazon →
Table of Contents
- Main Points
- Our Top Picks
- Plano Angled Tackle System with Three 3560 Stowaway Boxes, Fishing Tackle Storage, Premium Tackle Storage
- Flambeau Outdoors 6382TB 2-Tray Tackle Box - Classic Fishing Lure Storage Organizer, Medium Portable Tackle Box, 15 Tray Compartments, Blue/Gray
- PLUSINNO Large 4-Layer Tackle Box with Tackle Included, 547Pcs Fishing Lures Kit - Pliers, Crankbait, Hooks, Weights & Accessories - Freshwater Bass Fishing Bait Lure Gear and Equipment, Gift for Men
- Plano 3-Tray Tackle Box with Dual Top Access, Dark Green Metallic/Off White, Premium Tackle Storage
- Plano 2-Tray Tackle Box with Dual Top Access, Blue Metallic/Off White, Premium Tackle Storage, 620206, One Size
- Buying Guide
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
Main Points
- Modular designs that fit standard 3560 Stowaway trays give clean separation for trolling spoons and crankbaits, plus fast swaps between Western and Central Basin patterns.
- Dual-top or angled-access lids save precious seconds on the water—reach the right lure one-handed while steering or fighting a fish.
- Cold-water durability matters: rugged plastics, reinforced hinges, and secure latches keep lids shut in spray and chop.
- Capacity and layout matter for the season: three-tray, four-layer, or multi-level setups hold cranks, jigs, soft plastics, and weights without cross-contamination.
- Value-added features—included tackle and accessory pockets—cut prep time and let you switch from trolling to ice fishing with less hassle.
Our Top Picks
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
Plano Angled Tackle System with Three 3560 Stowaway Boxes, Fishing Tackle Storage, Premium Tackle Storage
🏆 Best For: Best for Large Tackle Kits
You earn the top spot as Best for Large Tackle Kits because this system keeps a full spread of rigs within arm’s reach and out of the gunwale spray. You’ll stack three 3560 Stowaway boxes on an angled base, giving you instant access to trolling spoons, crankbaits, jig heads, and plastics without crawling across a slippery deck. Western Basin trips demand quick rig changes and plenty of choice; this setup makes your tournament-style variety manageable from the cockpit.
Key features and real-world benefits: The three removable 3560 boxes are the workhorses, each holding a wide mix of jigs, spoons, and soft plastics with clear lids for fast ID. The angled design frees up deck space and makes access painless when the boat heels in Central Basin currents or fall chop. Built for cold-water boat handling, the sturdy plastic resists cracking when you bump rails and store multiple rigs for all-season trolling, jigging, and even ice-fishing prep between bites.
Who should buy this and when: This is the choice for guides, tournament teams, and serious anglers who run multiple rigs and want them ready to roll. If you fish Western Basin fall patterns, where walleyes hover 40–70 feet and perch push shallower at times, you’ll appreciate swapping between deep-water spoons and mid-depth jigs without unloading everything. It’s equally practical for spring pre-spawn trolling and late-season cold-water jigging, when time on the water equals money on the scoreboard.
Drawbacks or caveats: It’s not a fully waterproof box, so keep moisture out and dry up rig bins after a soaking rain. The setup can feel bulky on small boats or tight cockpits, and you’ll want to secure it firmly in heavy seas to prevent movement during a gusty crosswind off the islands.
✅ Pros
- Mass storage for rigs
- Quick-access design for trolling setups
- Detachable boxes for swapping seasons
❌ Cons
- Not fully waterproof
- Bulky on small boats
- Key Ingredient: Durable plastic with three 3560 boxes
- Scent Profile: N/A
- Best For: Best for Large Tackle Kits
- Size / Volume: Three 3560 boxes + angled base
- Special Feature: Angled stacking for quick reach
-
Flambeau Outdoors 6382TB 2-Tray Tackle Box - Classic Fishing Lure Storage Organizer, Medium Portable Tackle Box, 15 Tray Compartments, Blue/Gray
🏆 Best For: Best for Portable Storage
This box earns Best for Portable Storage with its compact, grab-and-go design. On Western Basin fall pattern days, you need fast deck access and light gear. The 2-tray, 15-compartment layout keeps spoons, jigs, and small cranks ready without hunting through a bigger box.
Key features and real-world benefits: The Flambeau 6382TB uses a two-tray setup with 15 fixed compartments. Small spoons, bucktails, and jigheads stay sorted and quick to grab. The blue/gray shell stays rigid in cold Erie water, with a secure latch that keeps contents from spilling in chop. It’s light enough for long boat runs yet sturdy enough for open-water trolling, jigging, or ice-gear transitions on a windy day.
Who should buy this and when: If you run solo or with a small crew, you want a core spread without a heavy locker. Ideal for Western Basin trolling setups and Central Basin jigging rigs, plus fall perch work on nearshore structures. Use one tray for spoons and bucktails, the other for small cranks and plastics.
Honest drawbacks or caveats: It’s not built for giant crankbaits or bulk plastics, so you’ll still need a larger tote for heavy gear. If you overload a tray, the dividers can flex, and the latches can loosen in rough seas; keep it lightly loaded for derby days.
✅ Pros
- Compact, portable for boat runs
- 15 compartments keep tiny tackle sorted
- Solid latch and cold-weather resilience
❌ Cons
- Limited space for large crankbaits
- Latches may loosen in rough seas
- Key Ingredient: 2-tray design with 15 compartments
- Scent Profile: N/A for tackle box plastics
- Best For: Best for Portable Storage
- Size / Volume: Medium, fits under seat or hatch
- Special Feature: Durable latch and carry handle
-
PLUSINNO Large 4-Layer Tackle Box with Tackle Included, 547Pcs Fishing Lures Kit - Pliers, Crankbait, Hooks, Weights & Accessories - Freshwater Bass Fishing Bait Lure Gear and Equipment, Gift for Men
🏆 Best For: Best All-in-One Starter Kit
That Best All-in-One Starter Kit honor comes from a single box that covers Western and Central Basin needs without swapping crates. The PLUSINNO 4-layer box stores a 547-piece lure kit plus pliers, crankbaits, hooks, weights, and the rest in a rugged, boat-ready shell. It streamlines prep for trolling and jigging, and the assortment stands up to Erie’s coldwater bite. You’ll cut setup time and widen your pattern options for fall walleye and perch on Erie.
Feature-rich for Lake Erie: four-layer compartments keep trolling rigs separate from jig setups; the 547 pieces cover spoons, crankbaits, and terminal tackles; the included pliers and weights let you adjust your spread on the fly; finishes hold up in cold water and on damp charter days.
For a new charter crew or weekend angler stepping into Erie, this kit is ideal. It covers Western Basin fall patterns and lets you mix slow-trolled crankbaits with vertical jigging and blade baits without swapping boxes. It’s also a solid backup on rough boat days when you need a broad range of baits handy.
Not a perfect pro-grade kit; some items are entry-level and might not stand up to heavy offshore use; the bass-gear bias means a few lures aren’t ideal for walleye directly, and you may want to add heavier jig heads for perch.
✅ Pros
- Consolidates 547-piece lure kit into one box
- Includes pliers and essential tools on board
- Durable, cold-water ready lures and finishes
❌ Cons
- Not all hooks sized for big walleye
- Not all lures tuned for Lake Erie walleye
- Key Ingredient: 547-piece lure kit
- Scent Profile: No added scents
- Best For: Best All-in-One Starter Kit
- Size / Volume: 4-layer box with 547 pieces
- Special Feature: Includes pliers and accessories
-
Plano 3-Tray Tackle Box with Dual Top Access, Dark Green Metallic/Off White, Premium Tackle Storage
🏆 Best For: Best for Easy Top Access
Best for Easy Top Access earns its position because the dual top lids let you grab spoons, jigs, or pliers without popping open the main compartment. That saves you seconds on a tight Erie troll or when you’re swapping a spoon to match a quick depth change. You’ll notice it most during fall patterns in the Central Basin, where rapid depth shifts demand fast, reliable access.
Three trays keep your most-used tackle organized—spoons, bucktails, glow jigs—so you can re-rig fast without dumping a tub. The shell’s dark green metallic with off-white interior shrugs off boat spray and chilly mornings, and the dual top access keeps a jig or crank at hand while you swap spoons at 25–40 feet as the walleye tighten up. It’s compact enough to sit in a console or slotted ice bucket, which matters when you’re bird-dogging perch in the Western Basin and need quick, repeatable access.
Who should buy this and when? If you run mid-size tackle on Erie for walleye and perch and value fast access during trolling or jigging, this box fits your pattern. Fall patters demand depth changes and rapid lure swaps; this setup keeps you efficient when time on the water is precious. It also works for ice anglers who want a small, sturdy top-access organizer for jig heads, spoons, and soft plastics.
Honest drawbacks: it isn’t a cavernous storage solution for a deep, all-in tackle load, so overflowists will want a second box or larger unit. In subzero temps the lids can become stiff and slow to flip, and it isn’t designed for heavy-duty saltwater use or brutal handling on rough launch days.
✅ Pros
- Dual top access saves retrieval time
- Three trays organize spoons, jigs, rigs
- Rugged enough for boat use on Erie
❌ Cons
- Limited capacity for heavy tackle loads
- Lids can seize in subzero
- Key Ingredient: Three-tray, dual-top access
- Scent Profile: Not applicable
- Best For: Easy top access in tight spaces
- Size / Volume: Compact boat storage
- Special Feature: Dual lids with secure latches
- Durability: Cold-ready plastic for Erie seasons
-
Plano 2-Tray Tackle Box with Dual Top Access, Blue Metallic/Off White, Premium Tackle Storage, 620206, One Size
🏆 Best For: Best Budget Dual-Top Box
Plano's 2-Tray Tackle Box with Dual Top Access earns Best Budget Dual-Top Box because it gives you solid organization and instant top access on a busy deck, all for under twenty dollars. In Western Basin trolling runs or Central Basin jig drops, that quick reach saves you seconds and fewer tangled lures.
Two trays let you separate crankbaits, jigs, and soft plastics, while the bottom compartment handles spare jig heads and leader packs. The blue metallic/off-white finish stays visible on a windy day and the plastic holds up to cold-water days and spray, which matters on Lake Erie spring and fall trips. The dual-top lid design means you can grab what you need while keeping your glove-warm hand on the rod.
Who should buy this? Seasoned Erie anglers who want a reliable backup that won't blow the budget. Use it for spring walleye and fall perch patrols, mixing shallow jigging with mid-depth trolling. In tournament contexts, it’s a pragmatic spare that rides on a deck or in a rod locker, accessible in seconds without unloading a bigger box.
Drawbacks? Capacity is modest; it’s not waterproof or crushproof, and the lid isn’t locking. If you’re packing a full long-day spread or heavy terminal tackle, you’ll outgrow it. For ice fishing gloves and mitten days, the trays can feel fiddly—great as a secondary box, not your main jig station.
✅ Pros
- Top-access trays speed on-deck bait changes
- Budget price fits tournament budgets
- Two trays organize crankbaits and jigs
❌ Cons
- Limited capacity vs larger pro boxes
- Not waterproof or crushproof
- Key Ingredient: Dual-top, two-tray design
- Scent Profile: Scent-free plastic
- Best For: Budget-minded Erie anglers
- Size / Volume: Compact 2-tray with bottom pocket
- Special Feature: Quick dual-top access lids
Factors to Consider
Frequently Asked Questions
What size tackle box is best for Lake Erie walleye jigging?
A mid‑size box with 2–3 shallow trays plus a deep tray works for most Erie jigging setups. It fits a solid mix of jigs, spoons, and plastics and leaves room to spare for a small spare reel or two.
Are waterproof tackle boxes worth it for Lake Erie?
Yes. You’ll see spray, drizzle, and occasional ice fog, and a true waterproof seal keeps tackle dry and prevents rust. Check gaskets and test the lid for a secure seal in cold weather.
How should I organize crankbaits and spoons in a tackle box?
Store large crankbaits in deeper compartments and smaller spoons in top trays with adjustable dividers. Keep jig heads and blades in separate sections to avoid tangling; label or color‑code bays for fast access during a drift or a run through a school.
Can I use a tackle box for ice fishing gear?
Absolutely. Choose a box with winter‑ready seals and easy access with bulky gloves. A rotomolded design or one with snug external pockets makes pulling jigs, blades, and line cutters in cold shack conditions simpler.
How do I clean and maintain tackle boxes after Lake Erie trips?
Rinse with fresh water, then dry completely before storing. Inspect hinges and latches for grit and lubricate sparingly with silicone where needed; store with a desiccant if you’ll be away from the boat for a while.
What features matter most for Western vs Central Basin conditions?
Western Basin trips benefit from deeper, wider compartments to handle bigger spoons and crankbaits for perch and walleye. Central Basin conditions favor quick‑access, glove‑friendly layouts and tighter trays that let you swap baits fast in cold water and windy mornings.
Do I need separate boxes or a single multi-tray box?
Two boxes are ideal: one stocked for trolling and big lures, the other for jigging and ice gear. You can shuttle the second box between boat, truck, and ice shack without wasting time reconfiguring everything.
