Best Jigging Spoons For Lake Erie Walleye
You're chasing Lake Erie bites, and the clock won't wait. From the hard edges of the Western Basin to the edges near the Central Strip, you’ll learn what works when fall patterns cool the water and walleye start feeding tight to structure. This roundup cuts through hype and sticks to real-world performance—cold-water durability, solid walleye and perch responses, and practical uses from trolling and jigging to ice setups. Depth that holds, bites captured, results that count on tournament days and weekend derbies.
⚡ Quick Answer: Best Lake Erie Fishing
Best for Night Fishing: Eupheng Fishing Rattle Spoon, Casting Spoon Lures Jigging Spoon for Saltwater & Freshwater Jigging, Trolling, Surf Fishing, Glow in Dark Spoons for Bass Walleye Perch Trout
$126.55 — Check price on Amazon →
Table of Contents
- Main Points
- Our Top Picks
- Eupheng Fishing Rattle Spoon, Casting Spoon Lures Jigging Spoon for Saltwater & Freshwater Jigging, Trolling, Surf Fishing, Glow in Dark Spoons for Bass Walleye Perch Trout
- Sougayilang Jigs Fishing Lures Sinking Metal Spoons Micro Jigging Bait
- THKFISH Fishing Lures Fishing Spoons Lures Trout Lures for Trout Pike bass Crappie Walleye 3.5g(1/8oz) 5.5g(1/5oz) 7.5g(1/4oz) 10.5g(3/8oz) 14.5g(1/2oz) 21.5g(3/4oz) 5pcs
- Blade Bait Bass Fishing Lures Blade Baits for Walleyes Metal VIB Lure, 6pcs 20g Sinking Jigging Spoons Hard Swimbait - 2.75in
- THKFISH Fishing Lures Fishing Spoons Lures Trout Lures for Trout Pike bass Crappie Walleye 3.5g(1/8oz) 5.5g(1/5oz) 7.5g(1/4oz) 10.5g(3/8oz) 14.5g(1/2oz) 21.5g(3/4oz) 5pcs
- Dovesun Ice Fishing Rattle Spoons Glow Ice Fishing Lures Ice Fishing jigs Accessories Gear Gifts for Walleye Bass Catfish Trout 3PCS/12PCS
- Dr.Fish 5 Pack Metal Jigging Spoon Saltwater Fishing Jigs Spoons Lures Casting Vertical Diamond Jig Lures Freshwater Bass Striper Mackerel Halibut
- Saltwater Jigs Fishing Lures with Ultra-Sharp Hooks, Saltwater Spoon Lure for Tuna Salmon Grouper, Sea Fishing Jigging Lure, Trolling Spoon for Bass Fishing
- Buying Guide
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
Main Points
- Weight by depth and season: 3.5–7.5 g spoons cover 15–40 ft jigging in Central Basin fall; 10.5–21.5 g spoons shine when Western Basin fish stay deeper or you’re trolling.
- Finish and glow matter: glow or UV finishes boost visibility in stained water or low light; carry a mix of glow, mirrored, and natural finishes.
- Versatility and action: choose spoons that perform both vertical jigging and light trolling; blade spoons and rattle spoons add extra action and sound for decisive bites.
- All-season value: multi-pack options with weights from 3.5 g to 21.5 g let you swing from ice to open water without swapping setups.
- Seasonal basin strategy: in fall, Central Basin responds to mid-range spoons on humps and saddles; Western Basin fish often sit deeper—adjust depth and technique to bite, not color.
Our Top Picks
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
Eupheng Fishing Rattle Spoon, Casting Spoon Lures Jigging Spoon for Saltwater & Freshwater Jigging, Trolling, Surf Fishing, Glow in Dark Spoons for Bass Walleye Perch Trout
🏆 Best For: Best for Night Fishing
Best for Night Fishing earns this spoon its top spot because the glow and rattle work together like a beacon in Erie’s murk. You’ll notice the soft, steady glow that reads through current and stain, and the rattling body that triggers bites when light is scarce. In the Western Basin’s post-sunset window and along Central Basin humps, that combination keeps walleye and perch locked on your lure long enough for a clean take. Build and finish handle cold-water days without losing action or visibility.
Key features and real-world benefits come together in real arc. Glow-in-the-dark coating offers long-lasting visibility in cool lake water; the internal rattle adds a sonic cue that draws fish from structure and temp breaks; it’s a versatile jigging/spoon that you can cast, jig, or troll with. You’ll stay productive whether you’re trolling 1.5–2 mph along a reef edge, vertical jigging from 12–30 feet, or ticking along a shallow weed line after dark. In fall patterns, it stays true from Western Basin weedy banks to Central Basin ridges, handling cold Erie conditions without losing bite rhythm.
Who should buy this and when: you’re the night-focused Erie angler chasing walleye and perch in fall and winter, especially if you run guide trips or hunt a tournament window where every bite counts after dark. Keep one rigged for offshore humps in the Central Basin and another for nearshore structure in the Western Basin. It also translates well to ice fishing—glow plus rattle helps locate bites through slush and low light, then the lure transitions back to open water when the season pivots.
Honest drawbacks or caveats: the glow finish is excellent, but its brightness fades after extended sun exposure; keep it out of direct sun between sessions. The lure is somewhat bulkier than ultra-light spoons, so it’s not ideal for the lightest setups or ultra-fast retrieves in tight quarters. If you’re chasing minute perch bites on calm days, you may prefer smaller profiles or a multi-species mix in your box.
✅ Pros
- Glows vividly in low light
- Rattle adds attraction
- Cold-water durable build
❌ Cons
- Glow fades after sun exposure
- Bulky for ultra-light rigs
- Key Ingredient: Glow-in-the-dark coating with rattles
- Scent Profile: Unscented
- Best For: Best for Night Fishing
- Size / Volume: Multi-weight options
- Special Feature: Rattle chamber + glow
-
Sougayilang Jigs Fishing Lures Sinking Metal Spoons Micro Jigging Bait
🏆 Best For: Best for Micro Jigging
This Sougayilang micro jigging spoon earns Best for Micro Jigging because its compact profile and fast sink let you cover water fast on Erie ledges. In the Western Basin, fall fronts push walleyes deep toward current seams, and this spoon drops into the bite window with a tight flutter that bigger spoons miss. In the Central Basin, where water can run clearer and drops are shorter, the micro jigging action still draws bites when slower rigs stall. In tournament conditions, you can grid a pattern—drop, read the bite, move, repeat—and stay ahead of the clock.
Key features and real-world benefits line up with Erie performance: a dense metal body for quick submersion, a bright finish that flashes in cold water, and a fluttering profile that triggers both walleye and perch. It shines when you’re vertical jigging 40-70 feet, or dipping it on a slow troll to keep fish honest in current. The micro size minimizes line tangles and lets you probe tight cover or ledge edges without spooking the fish.
Who should buy this? You, if you rely on micro jigging to pull bites from Erie schools in fall and into ice season. Use it on Western Basin structure in 40-70 feet during late September through November; in Central Basin, pattern it on 20-40 feet around weed lines and humps. Pair with a light 1/16–1/8 oz jig head, 6- to 12-pound tackle, and a deliberate, vertical cadence. On ice, it translates to perch opportunities when you’re drilling in the same depths near structure.
Drawbacks? The hooks are small and can bend on bigger fish; you’ll need to stay sharp and replace trebles when needed. The finish can nick in rocky bottoms, and the tiny lure requires precise line control to keep the flutter consistent in current. It isn’t a panacea for every day, but on Erie you’ll see days you can’t beat the micro jig bite without it.
✅ Pros
- Tight flutter on vertical jigging.
- Sinks fast to reach deeper fish.
- Clear color range for water clarity.
❌ Cons
- Tiny hooks bend on big walleyes.
- Requires sharp retie and care.
- Key Ingredient: Dense metal construction for quick sink
- Scent Profile: Scent-free; relies on flash and wobble
- Best For: Micro jigging in Lake Erie
- Size / Volume: 2.5–3.5 g micro spoons
- Special Feature: Keel-balanced design for stable flutter
-
THKFISH Fishing Lures Fishing Spoons Lures Trout Lures for Trout Pike bass Crappie Walleye 3.5g(1/8oz) 5.5g(1/5oz) 7.5g(1/4oz) 10.5g(3/8oz) 14.5g(1/2oz) 21.5g(3/4oz) 5pcs
🏆 Best For: Best for Trout
These THKFISH Multi-Species Spoons earn their spot by matching Erie’s bite across seasons and basins. They cover Western Basin walleye chatter and Central Basin perch holds without swapping tackles. The range spans 3.5g to 21.5g, so you can dial depth and action as the thermocline tightens in fall and the water cools for winter perch spreads. Built to endure cold Erie water, the finish stays bright and the wobble stays true when the bite goes hot.
Key features translate to real-world results: a clean wobble, strong flash, and reliable depth control for trolling, jigging, or ice fishing. In Western Basin fall patterns you can match bait at 20 to 60 feet with ease, from weedlines to drop-offs. The weight spread lets you keep your lure in the strike zone as the currents shift, and the durable construction handles both walleye fights and perch chips without shedding paint.
Who should buy this and when: you’re serious about Lake Erie, running Western and Central Basin patterns, and want a versatile set that covers multiple species from spring through ice. It’s a solid choice for pre-tournament prep when you need rapid depth changes, and for fall perch hunts where the bite runs along the ledges. They excel at trolling around 1.0–1.8 mph and work well for vertical jigging on structure from 30 to 60 feet.
Honest drawbacks or caveats: color options can be limited, and the heaviest sizes aren’t ideal for shallow weedlines. Some perch-only windows may favor smaller spoons, so you might want a separate micro-size set for tight-bite days.
✅ Pros
- Wide weight range for Erie depth control
- Durable cold-water finish holds up
- Effective on walleye, perch, and pike
❌ Cons
- Limited color options
- Size gaps may miss bite
- Key Ingredient: Durable steel/spoon blend
- Scent Profile: No added scent; rely on flash
- Best For: Walleye, perch, pike, bass on Erie
- Size / Volume: 3.5–21.5 g range
- Special Feature: Wide weight spread for quick depth matching
-
Blade Bait Bass Fishing Lures Blade Baits for Walleyes Metal VIB Lure, 6pcs 20g Sinking Jigging Spoons Hard Swimbait - 2.75in
🏆 Best For: Best for Walleyes
This is why it earns Best for Walleyes. The blade-bait combo fits Lake Erie cold-water needs. A 20g sinking jig with a 2.75in profile hits depth fast. Western Basin bites rise to flash and wobble. Fall patterns stack fish on mid-depth structure, you reach fast and stay there.
Six pieces per pack, 20g each, ready for vertical jigging. The 2.75-inch form keeps a natural tail kick without overburdening the drop. Sinking action puts you in the strike zone longer, especially in 30–60 feet Western Basin water. Durable metal blade resists cold and rust in steady Erie pressure.
If you chase Erie walleyes with jigging or vertical presentations, this set belongs in your box. Fall shallow-to-mid-depth patterns, winter ice checks, and central-basin ledge drifts all respond to its cadence. Use 28–40 feet near weedlines in fall, 40–70 feet on humps in Central Basin. In tournament days, consistency matters, and this package delivers repeatable bites when the bite window opens.
Price is up for a six-pack. Not ideal for very shallow weedlines.
✅ Pros
- Great walleye trigger with blade flash
- Solid cold-water durability and finish
- Effective at 20–60 ft depths for jigging
❌ Cons
- Price premium may deter budget anglers
- Not ideal for weedless shallow water
- Key Ingredient: High-grade blade metal with VIB action
- Scent Profile: Neutral odor, no added attractant
- Best For: Best for Walleyes
- Size / Volume: 6 pcs, 20 g each, 2.75 inches
- Special Feature: Sinking jigging spoons with blade wobble
-
THKFISH Fishing Lures Fishing Spoons Lures Trout Lures for Trout Pike bass Crappie Walleye 3.5g(1/8oz) 5.5g(1/5oz) 7.5g(1/4oz) 10.5g(3/8oz) 14.5g(1/2oz) 21.5g(3/4oz) 5pcs
🏆 Best For: Multi-Species Spoons
These THKFISH Multi-Species Spoons earn their spot by matching Erie’s bite across seasons and basins. They cover Western Basin walleye chatter and Central Basin perch holds without swapping tackles. The range spans 3.5g to 21.5g, so you can dial depth and action as the thermocline tightens in fall and the water cools for winter perch spreads. Built to endure cold Erie water, the finish stays bright and the wobble stays true when the bite goes hot.
Key features translate to real-world results: a clean wobble, strong flash, and reliable depth control for trolling, jigging, or ice fishing. In Western Basin fall patterns you can match bait at 20 to 60 feet with ease, from weedlines to drop-offs. The weight spread lets you keep your lure in the strike zone as the currents shift, and the durable construction handles both walleye fights and perch chips without shedding paint.
Who should buy this and when: you’re serious about Lake Erie, running Western and Central Basin patterns, and want a versatile set that covers multiple species from spring through ice. It’s a solid choice for pre-tournament prep when you need rapid depth changes, and for fall perch hunts where the bite runs along the ledges. They excel at trolling around 1.0–1.8 mph and work well for vertical jigging on structure from 30 to 60 feet.
Honest drawbacks or caveats: color options can be limited, and the heaviest sizes aren’t ideal for shallow weedlines. Some perch-only windows may favor smaller spoons, so you might want a separate micro-size set for tight-bite days.
✅ Pros
- Wide weight range for Erie depth control
- Durable cold-water finish holds up
- Effective on walleye, perch, and pike
❌ Cons
- Limited color options
- Size gaps may miss bite
- Key Ingredient: Durable steel/spoon blend
- Scent Profile: No added scent; rely on flash
- Best For: Walleye, perch, pike, bass on Erie
- Size / Volume: 3.5–21.5 g range
- Special Feature: Wide weight spread for quick depth matching
-
Dovesun Ice Fishing Rattle Spoons Glow Ice Fishing Lures Ice Fishing jigs Accessories Gear Gifts for Walleye Bass Catfish Trout 3PCS/12PCS
🏆 Best For: Best for Ice Fishing
Best for Ice Fishing because the Dovesun Glow Ice Fishing Rattle Spoons pull walleye and perch to the surface when Erie ice glare and murk reduce visibility. This 3PCS/12PCS kit gives you the depth and color spread you need, from Western Basin’s stained, wind-driven bays to Central Basin’s clear, deeper structure. Built to endure subzero slush and the hard thump of ice, they keep their glow and their rattle bite trip after trip.
Key features and real-world benefits: the glow finish cuts through low light and stained water, making your lure visible when daylight fades or water is dirty. A built-in rattle adds vibration that triggers bite as you jig or work a tip-down setup. With 3-piece or 12-piece options, you can mix sizes to cover 15-40 feet quickly and adapt to wind shifts and water color. They perform well for jigging over structure, and you can pair them with a live minnow or waxworm for a confident presentation in tough Erie conditions.
Who should buy this and when: you’re serious about winter walleye and perch on Lake Erie and you fish December through February, especially when Western Basin water is off color or Central Basin water is clear but bluebird days demand flash. In tournament contexts, this kit lets you dial depth and color on the fly as patterns shift day to day. Use a steady jig cadence—two quick lifts, a short pause, then a controlled fall—and swap to a live bait presentation to seal the bite on humps, points, and trench edges.
Honest drawbacks: in bright, clean days the glow can be less noticeable, so you’ll want a complementary color or pattern. The 12-piece option is bulky for short trips and can overwhelm a single tackle box. And if you’re fishing ultra-tight into crystal-clear water, the rattles may spook extra wary fish unless you rotate to quieter spoons.
✅ Pros
- Glow draws bites in cold water
- Multiple sizes in one set
- Rattle adds alerting bite signals
❌ Cons
- Ice-only use; limited open-water value
- 12-piece kit can be bulky
- Key Ingredient: Glow finish with rattle beads
- Scent Profile: No added scent; relies on glow and noise
- Best For: Ice fishing for Walleye and Perch on Lake Erie
- Size / Volume: 3PCS or 12PCS sets
- Special Feature: Built-in rattle; glow-in-the-dark lure
-
Dr.Fish 5 Pack Metal Jigging Spoon Saltwater Fishing Jigs Spoons Lures Casting Vertical Diamond Jig Lures Freshwater Bass Striper Mackerel Halibut
🏆 Best For: Best for Versatile Waters
This pack earns the Best for Versatile Waters label because it covers the Erie equation you live for—Western Basin versatility from shallow rock bars to the deeper, current-ted zones of the Central Basin. With five spoons in one kit, you’re not guessing depth or action on a tournament day; you’ve got the options to adapt fast as water clears, winds shift, or bites go quiet. In fall, when walleye tighten to mid-depths and chase bait along weedlines, this assortment keeps you in the bite without swapping lures.
Key features translate to real-world advantages on Lake Erie: rugged metal construction for cold-water durability, a diamond profile that delivers a balanced fall and a subtle wobble, and a calm, predictable retrieve that plays well with jigging and casting. The five-pack format lets you dial depth and tempo with current speed and structure, whether you’re vertical jigging off a shoal, slow-trolling along a humps edge, or hunting suspended fish in clean water. They perform well under the conditions you face in Western vs. Central Basin setups and during fall’s bite windows.
Who should buy this? If you hunt Erie year-round with a tournament mindset or a serious weekend schedule, you’ll appreciate the coverage across basins and seasons. Use them in spring pre-spawn and fall peak when walleye and perch respond to fast, reflective jigging. In Western Basin, target shallower weedlines and drop-offs from 15 to 25 feet; in Central Basin, work deeper structure from 40 to 70 feet. The 5-pack format lets you adjust on the water—swap spoons rather than swap entire rigs when the bite shifts.
One caveat: weights aren’t listed, so you’ll need to experiment to dial your depth precisely. Some spoons may require hook maintenance or upgrades if you’re chasing stubborn Erie bites. Overall, the versatility and real-world performance in cold water and across lake conditions make this a solid addition to a serious Erie spread.
✅ Pros
- Flexible depth and action options
- Durable metal for cold water
- Effective on walleye and perch
❌ Cons
- No weights listed
- Some spoons may need hook tweaks
- Key Ingredient: Metal jigging spoons
- Scent Profile: Scent-free/natural finish
- Best For: Best for Versatile Waters
- Size / Volume: 5-pack with variants
- Special Feature: Diamond shape for wobble and bite
-
Saltwater Jigs Fishing Lures with Ultra-Sharp Hooks, Saltwater Spoon Lure for Tuna Salmon Grouper, Sea Fishing Jigging Lure, Trolling Spoon for Bass Fishing
🏆 Best For: Best for Saltwater Giants
This Best for Saltwater Giants designation isn’t marketing fluff. It comes from a rugged, saltwater-grade build and ultra-sharp hooks that stand up to big hits and long runs, the kind you chase in deep-water Lake Erie. In fall patterns across the Western and Central Basins, you need a spoon that holds depth, resists the chill, and triggers bites on walleyes staged on structure 60 to 120 feet down. This lure delivers that stability and bite-caliber two-step you want when you’re covering water behind boards or dropping straight down for a vertical jig session.
Key features and real-world benefits show up in the way this spoon handles Erie’s cold water. The ultra-sharp hooks deliver clean, rapid hookups on wary eyes, and the heavy profile keeps a solid wobble and flash at depth. Whether you’re trolling 1.5–2 mph along ledges in the Western Basin or jigging 60–100 feet in mid-lall fall, the lure tracks true and resists fouling in current. Durable construction means you can push through long derby days without worrying about failure, a real advantage on tournament weekends when conditions swing from glass to chop.
Who should buy this and when? If you’re chasing larger walleyes or aggressive fall fish on Lake Erie, this spoon earns its keep. Use it behind planner boards or downriggers to cover 70–120 feet in Western Basin structure, and switch to vertical jigging from 40–90 feet when marks tighten up in Central Basin flats. It’s not ideal for shallow weed bites or early-season perch in tight schooling situations, but in fall tournament windows it shines as a deep-water option you can trust to reach the bite.
Honest drawbacks? It’s a premium spend for a single spoon, and the heavy profile isn’t forgiving in shallow water or tight schools. Color options are limited, and it’s not designed for ice-fishing setups. You’ll want a solid rod and reel combo capable of handling the weight and a bit of wind when you’re running long drifts on Erie’s big water.
✅ Pros
- Ultra-sharp hooks promote quick hookups
- Tracks true in cold, deep water
- Durable build for long runs
❌ Cons
- Expensive for a single spoon
- Heavy for shallow water
- Key Ingredient: Ultra-sharp hooks
- Scent Profile: No added scent
- Best For: Best for Saltwater Giants
- Size / Volume: Heavy-weight, deep-water spoon
- Special Feature: Stable tracking in cold water
Factors to Consider
Frequently Asked Questions
What weight should I start with for Lake Erie walleye jigging spoons?
Start with 3/8 to 1/2 oz for 20-50 feet and adjust up to 5/8-3/4 oz for 60-100 feet, depending on depth, current, and water clarity.
Do jigging spoons work better in the Western Basin or Central Basin?
Both basins produce bites, but Western Basin’s clearer water and deeper edges respond to natural patterns, while Central Basin often needs brighter or chartreuse finishes to cut through stain and weed.
Is jigging with spoons better than trolling for Erie walleye?
You’ll mix tactics. Jigging hammers bites on deep edges and post-spawn fish, while slow-trolling helps cover water and find active schools.
Should I tip spoons with soft plastics or minnows?
Tipping can boost attraction and slow fall. A small paddle-tail plastic or minnow-imitating piece on the hook often helps in tough light or stained water.
What season and depth patterns should I target with jigging spoons?
Fall bites come on structure around 40-80 feet as fish stack on edges; spring bites tend to move shallower, so start around 20-40 feet. In deeper winter windows, you’ll find activity on the edge around 60-100 feet when currents cooperate.
What rod and line setup works best with jigging spoons on Lake Erie?
Use a 7' to 7'6" medium-light to medium rod with a fast tip, paired to 12-20 lb fluorocarbon leader and 15-30 lb braided mainline.
Keep line tight to feel subtle taps and to set quickly on a bite, especially in clear water.
Are jigging spoons useful for ice fishing on Lake Erie?
Yes. In winter, use smaller spoons (1/8-1/4 oz) with wax worm or minnow, jigging vertical in 20-40 feet and pausing to draw bites.
