10 Best Walleye Lures for Lake Erie – Expert Picks for Successful Fishing

To catch more walleye on Lake Erie, use these top expert picks. Start with Berkley Walleye Rigs with Indiana blades for versatile fishing. Bandit’s BDTB, BDTWBD, and Deep Crankbait (Sprinkles) dive deep, attracting fish with their vibrant colors. Cotton Cordell Wally Diver is proven effective too. For trolling depth, try Bandit’s Deep Peacock and Reflection lures. Don’t miss Carlson Erie Dearie Original Silver, known for its durability. Consider lure action, hook strength, and trolling speeds. Adjust according to water depth and season for best results. Want to know how these lures can transform your fishing game? Let’s continue.

Main Points

• Berkley Walleye Rigs: Effective, durable, and highly rated; built with Berkley Trilene XT monofilament line and Indiana #4 blades.
• Bandit Lures BDTB: Dives 17-18 feet, features tight aggressive action, and is neutrally buoyant.
• Bandit Lures BDTWBD: Versatile with effective color patterns and 3D eyes, but only available in Blue Shiner.
• Cotton Cordell Wally Diver: Proven to catch walleye, versatile with various sizes and colors, though paint quality may vary.
• Carlson Erie Dearie Original: Highly rated, versatile with durable Mustad hook, suitable for various fishing techniques.

Berkley® Walleye Rigs – Indiana,42- Inch Hammered Silver

If you’re an angler looking for a durable and effective rig for Lake Erie, the Berkley® Walleye Rigs – Indiana, 42-Inch Hammered Silver is an excellent choice. This rig, designed with Berkley Trilene XT monofilament line and Indiana #4 blades, is ideal for using minnows, leeches, and 1/2 crawlers.

With its 42-inch length and 4-inch triple hook, it’s built to withstand the abuse from avid anglers. Customers have praised its effectiveness in catching a variety of fish species, though some noted the 12-pound-test line mightn’t be durable enough for Northern Pike.

Despite occasional issues with receiving the wrong color, the overall quality remains high, reflected in its 4.3 out of 5-star rating from 136 reviews.

Best For: Avid anglers looking for a durable and effective rig for catching various fish species in Lake Erie.

Pros:

• High effectiveness in catching multiple fish species
• Built with durable Berkley Trilene XT monofilament line and Indiana #4 blades
• Positive customer reviews with a 4.3 out of 5-star rating

Cons:

• 12-pound-test monofilament line may not be durable enough for Northern Pike
• Occasional issues with receiving the wrong color
• Mixed feedback on pricing and value for money offered by the product

Bandit Lures BDTB

Boasting a neutrally buoyant design and proven tight, aggressive action, the Bandit Lures BDTB is perfect for anglers targeting walleye in Lake Erie. This pre-weighted and precision-balanced lure stays in the strike zone at all times. It’s designed to dive 17-18 feet when trolled at 1.5-2 mph on 15 lb braid, making it ideal for deep-water fishing.

The BDTB’s third hook increases your chances of landing more walleye, ensuring you don’t miss that big catch. With positive customer reviews praising its performance, diving ability, and durability, this lure is a reliable choice. Available in a striking Black Pink/Yel Head color, it’s no wonder it ranks high among fishing plugs.

Give the Bandit Lures BDTB a try on your next Lake Erie adventure.

Best For: Anglers targeting walleye in deep-water fishing, particularly in Lake Erie.

Pros:

• Neutrally buoyant design with tight, aggressive action
• Dives 17-18 feet when trolled at optimal speed
• Third hook increases chances of landing more fish

Cons:

• Mixed reviews on functionality and need for refills to light up
• Some comments on the lure’s color and price
• Limited to specific target species (walleye)

Bandit Lures BDTWBD

When you’re after walleye in Lake Erie, the Bandit Lures BDTWBD stands out with its 4.5-inch slender minnow design and effective color patterns, making it a top choice for serious anglers.

This lure’s Blue Shiner color and 3D eyes attract walleye, bass, pike, and zander, guaranteeing you’re prepared for various predator fish.

The integral lip allows the lure to troll at a depth of 12 feet, providing reliable performance in deeper waters. Tough trebles ensure you won’t lose your catch, and its multiple fishing techniques make it versatile.

Users love its effectiveness, evidenced by a 4.6-star rating. Priced competitively, this Bandit Lure is a must-have for anyone aiming for success on Lake Erie.

Best For: Serious anglers targeting walleye, bass, pike, and other predator fish in deeper waters.

Pros:

• Effective color patterns and 3D eyes for attracting predator fish
• Integral lip for true running toughness and 12-feet trolling depth
• Versatile for multiple fishing techniques

Cons:

• Some users may find the price higher compared to other lures
• Limited to a single color option (Blue Shiner)
• Item dimensions listed may be confusing or incorrect

Bandit BDTWBD2B84 Walleye Deep Crankbait – Sprinkles (4-3/4 inch, 5/8oz)

The Bandit BDTWBD2B84 Walleye Deep Crankbait – Sprinkles is ideal for anglers targeting walleye and other predator fish in Lake Erie. This crankbait is designed to get deep quickly and maintain a true track at various speeds. It measures 4-3/4 inches and weighs 5/8oz, boasting a rolling wobble that irresistibly attracts walleye, zander, and more.

Equipped with quality hooks, this crankbait is a reliable addition to any trolling setup. The multi-colored design enhances visibility, making it even more effective in murky waters. Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars by satisfied customers, you can trust its performance.

Don’t overlook this modern, high-quality crankbait if you’re aiming for a successful fishing trip on Lake Erie.

Best For: Anglers targeting walleye and other predator fish in Lake Erie who need a reliable and deep-diving crankbait.

Pros:

• Gets deep quickly and maintains a true track at various speeds.
• Rolling wobble effectively attracts predator fish like walleye and zander.
• Equipped with high-quality hooks and a multi-colored design for enhanced visibility.

Cons:

• Limited to one size option, which may not suit all fishing needs.
• Only available in a single piece per package.
• Higher price point compared to some other crankbaits.

Cotton Cordell Wally Diver Walleye Crankbait Fishing Lure

For anglers targeting walleye in Lake Erie, Cotton Cordell’s Wally Diver offers a tournament-caliber performance with its slender profile and tight wiggle. Proven effective on the Great Lakes, this crankbait is available in various sizes and color patterns, such as the popular Chartreuse/Blue Tiger.

The Wally Diver’s 1/2 oz size and suspending model make it versatile for different fishing techniques. Customers love its bright colors, great action, and reasonable pricing, though some mentioned paint quality issues. With an average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars from 723 ratings, it’s clear that many have had success catching walleye, northern pike, and even largemouth bass.

You’ll appreciate its durable construction and ability to reach depths up to 20 feet.

Best For: Anglers targeting walleye and other fish species in varied fishing environments, especially on the Great Lakes.

Pros:

• Proven effectiveness in catching walleye and other species.
• Bright colors and great action enhance its appeal to fish.
• Versatile with different sizes and color patterns.

Cons:

• Some users reported issues with paint quality.
• Size may be smaller than expected.
• Limited to a specific range of target species.

Bill Lewis Fishing Lipless Lifelike Trolling Precise Walleye Crankbait

Looking for a lure that dives deep and hits the strike zone quickly? The Bill Lewis Fishing Lipless Lifelike Trolling Precise Walleye Crankbait is your go-to choice. This crankbait, in the Erie Shad color, is designed specifically for precision trolling. It reaches depths up to 33 feet, making it perfect for targeting walleye in Lake Erie.

The enhanced hook design with Mustad Triple Grip hooks guarantees your catch stays secure.

Measuring 1 x 1 x 1 inches and weighing just 0.05 kilograms, it’s compact yet effective. Whether you’re casting or cranking, its lifelike appearance will attract bass, perch, and walleye. Manufactured by GSM Outdoors, this lure is a solid addition to your fishing arsenal.

Best For: Anglers targeting walleye, bass, and perch who need a deep-diving, precision-trolling crankbait.

Pros:

• Precision-trolling design for quicker strike zone access
• Depth capability up to 33 ft, ideal for deep-water fishing
• Enhanced hook design with Mustad Triple Grip hooks for secure catches

Cons:

• Customer reviews indicate a low satisfaction rating (2.0 out of 5 stars)
• Limited warranty might not cover all potential issues
• Package dimensions may indicate a compact size, potentially limiting visibility in larger bodies of water

Bandit Lures BDTWBD2B14 Walleye Deep Sunspot

Ideal for anglers targeting deep-water predators, the Bandit Lures BDTWBD2B14 Walleye Deep Sunspot offers unmatched performance with its ability to dive down to 27 feet. This lure, made in China, is a standout thanks to its vibrant Sunspot color and effective design. Measuring 4-3/4 inches and weighing 5/8 ounce, it features a round lip for quick and true diving. It’s perfect for walleye, zander, and other predator fish.

Customers rave about its great action and rattle, reporting numerous successful catches, including walleye and stripers. The lure works perfectly out of the box, making it a reliable choice right from the start. With a 4.9-star rating, it’s clear why the Bandit Lures BDTWBD2B14 is a top pick for Lake Erie fishing.

Best For: Anglers targeting deep-water predator fish such as walleye and zander.

Pros:

• Great action and rattle for attracting fish.
• Dives down to 27 feet, ideal for deep-water fishing.
• Works perfectly out of the box with no adjustments needed.

Cons:

• Limited to one color option.
• Only one piece included in the package.
• Made in China, which may be a concern for some buyers.

Bandit Lures BDTWBD2B25 Walleye Deep Peacock, 4 3/4

Anglers targeting walleye in Lake Erie will appreciate the Bandit Lures BDTWBD2B25 Walleye Deep Peacock for its ability to troll down to 27 feet, making it a top choice for deep-water fishing.

This 4 3/4-inch lure, weighing 0.63 ounces, features a peacock color that attracts walleye, zander, and other predator fish. Manufactured by Pradco Outdoor Brands, it boasts a round lip for quick and true diving, ensuring your lure reaches the desired depth efficiently.

With a perfect 5.0-star rating from customers, it’s evident that this lure delivers results. The Bandit Walleye Deep Peacock is a popular choice among anglers worldwide, and its effectiveness in Lake Erie makes it a must-have for your tackle box.

Best For: Anglers targeting deep-water predator fish such as walleye and zander, particularly in large bodies of water like Lake Erie.

Pros:

• Effective trolling depth of up to 27 feet.
• High customer satisfaction with a 5.0-star rating.
• Durable design with a round lip for quick and true diving.

Cons:

• Limited to deep-water fishing applications.
• Made in China, which may concern some buyers.
• Not the most affordable option on the market.

Bandit Lures BDTWBD2B21 Walleye Deep Reflection, 4 3/4

For those targeting walleye in Lake Erie’s deeper waters, the Bandit Lures BDTWBD2B21 Walleye Deep Reflection, measuring 4 3/4 inches, offers unmatched depth and accuracy. This lure is designed to dive quickly and precisely to depths of up to 27 feet, making it ideal for trolling.

Weighing 5/8 ounce, it features a round lip that guarantees a swift, accurate descent. The reflective color adds an extra allure, attracting not just walleye but other predator fish like Zander.

Manufactured by Pradco Outdoor Brands, this plastic lure is popular among anglers worldwide and boasts a solid 4.5 out of 5 stars from 18 customer reviews. It’s a must-have for any serious Lake Erie angler.

Best For: Anglers targeting walleye and other predator fish in deeper waters, particularly in Lake Erie.

Pros:

• Effective for trolling down to 27 feet.
• Reflective color attracts a variety of predator fish.
• Highly rated by customers with a 4.5 out of 5 stars.

Cons:

• Limited to one piece per package.
• Specific design may not suit shallow water fishing.
• Slightly higher price point compared to similar lures.

Carlson Erie Dearie Original Silver Fishing Lure

Designed by Captain Dan Galbincea, the Carlson Erie Dearie Original Silver Fishing Lure is perfect for those looking to enhance their trolling, casting, or wind drift fishing techniques.

This weight-forward spinner is an ideal choice for all gamefish, making it a versatile addition to your fishing gear. Featuring a Mustad hook, it’s built to last and consistently performs well.

With a sleek silver color and a modern style, this 3.8-ounce lure guarantees you’re well-equipped for a successful fishing trip. Customers love it, giving it a perfect 5-star rating.

It’s particularly effective for trolling, as many seasoned anglers attest. If you’re targeting species like tuna, this lure won’t disappoint. Keep this classic in your tackle box for reliable results on Lake Erie.

Best For: Anglers looking for a versatile and reliable lure for trolling, casting, or wind drift fishing, particularly effective for targeting gamefish like tuna.

Pros:

• Features a durable Mustad hook
• Highly rated with a perfect 5-star review from customers
• Versatile for various fishing techniques including trolling, casting, and wind drift fishing

Cons:

• Only available in a single piece per package
• May be considered heavy by some anglers at 3.8 ounces
• Specific targeting for tuna might limit its use for other species

Factors to Consider When Choosing Walleye Lures for Lake Erie

When selecting walleye lures for Lake Erie, you need to think about water depth preferences and lure color selection.

It’s also important to take into account the action and movement of the lure, as well as the durability of the hook.

Water Depth Preferences

To effectively choose walleye lures for Lake Erie, you need to understand how their water depth preferences change with the seasons. In the spring and fall, walleye are commonly found in shallower waters closer to the shore. They move into these areas to feed and spawn, making it an essential time to use lures that work well in shallow waters, such as crankbaits or jigs. These lures can effectively mimic the prey walleye are chasing during these seasons.

As summer rolls around, walleye shift to deeper waters to find cooler temperatures and their preferred prey. During this time, you’ll need to adjust your lure selection to target these deeper areas. Consider using deep-diving crankbaits or bottom bouncers paired with spinners to reach the depths where walleye are hiding. Additionally, trolling can be an effective technique to cover a larger area and locate schools of walleye in deeper waters.

Understanding walleye’s seasonal depth preferences is vital for successful fishing on Lake Erie. By adjusting your lure selection and techniques to match these depth changes, you’ll increase your chances of a productive fishing trip, regardless of the time of year.

Lure Color Selection

Selecting the right lure color can have a significant impact on your success when fishing for walleye in Lake Erie. Begin by taking into account the natural prey of walleye in the area, such as shad, smelt, or perch. Imitating these baitfish with your lure colors will enhance your presentation’s credibility.

In murky or stained waters, bright and fluorescent colors like chartreuse, pink, and orange can be extremely effective. These vibrant hues help your lures stand out, increasing their visibility to walleye.

Conversely, on sunny days or in clear water conditions, opt for more natural and subtle colors like silver, white, or natural patterns. These choices mimic real baitfish, improving your chances of attracting a walleye.

Water clarity and light conditions are important factors to take into account when selecting lure colors. The visibility of your lure may vary depending on how light penetrates the water and how walleye perceive colors. It’s a good idea to experiment with different colors and patterns under various conditions.

Walleye can be selective, and elements such as water temperature, depth, and weather patterns can impact their preferences. By paying attention to these details, you’ll be better equipped to choose the perfect lure color for any situation.

Action and Movement

Selecting walleye lures for Lake Erie requires careful consideration of their action and movement to effectively mimic the local baitfish. You’ll want lures that exhibit a natural action, as this will be more enticing to walleye. Opt for lures that can dive to the depths where walleye are commonly found, ensuring they stay within the strike zone.

A tight wobble or rolling action is particularly attractive to walleye. These movements closely resemble the swimming patterns of the fish they prey on, making your lure more convincing. Additionally, lures with erratic movements or vibrations can trigger a feeding response, especially when walleye are in a more aggressive mood.

In murky or deeper waters, consider lures with built-in rattles or noise-making features. These can add an extra layer of attraction, helping your lure stand out in less visible conditions. The combination of sound and movement can be the difference between a successful outing and a quiet day on the water.

Hook Durability

When selecting walleye lures for Lake Erie, it’s important to consider the durability of the hooks to make sure they can withstand the fight. You’ll want to focus on the material and construction of the hooks. High-quality hooks made from materials like stainless steel or Mustad hooks are excellent choices known for their strength and sharpness. These materials ensure that the hooks aren’t only sturdy but also resistant to bending and breaking, which is vital when you’re battling a feisty walleye or other predator fish.

Don’t forget to check customer reviews and feedback on specific lures. Real-world experiences can give you valuable insights into the hook’s performance and durability. Opt for lures that feature reinforced or premium hooks. These hooks are designed to prevent failures during intense fights, reducing the risk of losing your catch.

Additionally, make sure the hooks are rust-resistant. This feature will help maintain their sharpness and strength over time, especially in freshwater environments like Lake Erie. Rust-resistant hooks will last longer, providing you with reliable performance season after season.

Trolling Speed Compatibility

After ensuring your hooks are durable, it’s equally important to focus on trolling speed compatibility for your walleye lures in Lake Erie. Most walleye lures perform best at trolling speeds between 1.5 to 2 mph. You’ll want to choose lures that can maintain their depth and action at these speeds to effectively target walleye under various conditions.

Consider lures with adjustable diving depths or diving lips. These features let you control the lure’s presentation based on your trolling speed, ensuring it stays in the strike zone. Lures specifically designed for trolling are your best choice since they track true and exhibit the desired action at the recommended speeds.

Understanding the ideal trolling speed range for your chosen walleye lure is key to maximizing its effectiveness. When you select lures that work well within this range, you increase your chances of enticing strikes from Lake Erie’s walleye population.

Conclusion

When you’re out on Lake Erie, picking the right walleye lures can make or break your fishing trip. From Bandit’s deep crankbaits to Carlson’s Erie Dearie, these expert picks won’t let you down.

But here’s a theory worth testing: some anglers believe that lure color changes with water clarity can double your catch. Don’t just take their word for it—try it yourself and see if it boosts your success.

Happy fishing!